Friday, December 21, 2018

Finalized Research Paper

         Someone’s home gets intruded. He feels the immense sense of dread come over him as he realizes his privacy has been breached. His inner sanctum was not as safe as once thought. Invasions of homes and their occupant’s privacy happen daily. Some of these break-ins are caused by people who had been pre-meditating it. Burglars do this pre-meditating in many ways; one of the new ways that have developed within the past few years was the hacking and/or monitoring of the Amazon Key. Due to the introduction of the Amazon Key into society, the way privacy has been breached has begun to spread into many different forms. People feel that privacy being invaded is a one-way street; it is not. Privacy rules being broken can affect the breached/victim and the breacher/ “criminal”.
 What is privacy? Privacy is described as “The state or condition of being alone, undisturbed, or free from public attention, as a matter of choice or right,” (Oxford English Dictionary, 2018). When read correctly this statement strongly applies to someone's home. One's home should be a place that the owner is supposed to feel undisturbed, and free from public attention. With the introduction of the Amazon Key, this premise is gone. The Amazon Key comes with a keypad that can unlock people’s doors, a camera pointed at the door on the inside of their home, and an app on their phone with which they can monitor the camera.
           How is the Amazon Key an invasion of privacy? One way is the owner can use the camera to watch a delivery, but that also leaves yet another device that is always connected to the internet in the home that can be hacked. A vulnerability to this method is, “In Ethernet and Wireless LAN every client using the same medium receives the same signals. In MAC layer it is checked whether the packet is belong[ing] to me or not. If the packet is destined to its own address it is dropped. This part of the protocol is a backdoor for attackers,” (TEKDOĞAN, 2018). The quote refers to a Wi-Fi signal and the Amazon Key connects to the internet though these Wi-Fi connections. Someone can hack into that connection through the means described; all they need to do is get through that backdoor. By getting though that backdoor they enable themselves to connect to any device connected to the Wi-Fi signal, such as the Amazon Key, making it so they can observe the camera’s live feed. Also, when people are not monitoring the camera, or even when they are, there could be someone else, entirely random, using it too. Allowing this device into a home leaves an open source of video feed which can essentially be accessed by anyone. This means hackers, or others watching though this camera, would know the owner’s schedule and when the house would be left vacant to burglarize.
Another way in which the Amazon Key’s camera could be used against society and people’s privacy is that the camera can be frozen. Not physically, by using a simple coding program on a computer within range of the camera some criminals, or ‘faux delivery people’, could freeze the feed. “Based on the simplicity of the attack $20 and some freely available software, you can implement this yourself,” (CBS News, 2018) On that frozen video feed there is just a closed door showing on the camera while the door is wide open and the homeowner is being robbed. This frozen video feed can last until the attacker lets it go back to the normal feed.
           Although the privacy of the homeowner is breached immensely, there is also the privacy of the delivery man or woman that is broken. While they are just doing their job, they are being recorded with each delivery. Similarly to police body cameras, these workers have a camera that watches their every move. The watching is in shorter intervals for the delivery people and happens in bursts throughout the day but it is still an invasion of privacy that must not feel comfortable. By making these workers feel uncomfortable and watched they will be more likely to quit and or sabotage the company. Since there is the parallel to the cops having body cameras, there is also that fact that soon if Amazon wishes to make these deliveries even safer they may implement their own body cameras for the workers. These body cameras “will capture footage of [people] going to the bathroom, eating lunch, and having cell phone conversations with their loved ones or getting a call from the doctor,” (Chief Brandon del Pozo, 2018). By all of these things being able to happen the workers morale will drop due to the eavesdropping into their life from their own company of work.
        The Amazon Key also introduces the carrier/ delivery person into a home that he/she know nothing about. These homes that he/she must enter, be it for a brief time, exposes him/her to the elements within that home. The carrier may be allergic to what is in that house, whether it be cleaning products, animals, air fresheners, etc. Anyone can be allergic to anything. This breaks through the carrier’s privacy barriers by making the delivery person feel unsafe and exposed to a public space without their permission. “Any employee or representative of employees, who believes that an unsafe or unhealthful working condition exists in any workplace where such employee is employed, shall have the right and is encouraged to make a report of the unsafe or unhealthful working condition to an appropriate agency safety and health official and request an inspection of such workplace for this purpose,” (United States Department of Labor, 1960). By the companies putting their employees in such unsafe work conditions they could cost themselves millions of dollars in law suits of unsafe working conditions. By the company making the delivery people go into random homes and make them face the elements within that home they are being forced to do something that breaches their privacy.
        Although members of society have become accustomed to the constant watching of cameras in their lives, this is just another added expense which can cause them to lose everything. The people including those that have Amazon Prime, a paid membership that means not having to pay for 2-day shipping from Amazon.com, have had a rate of disapproval which has reached almost 70%. The actual statistic of the “Amazon Key... is a wildly unpopular concept so far. In a recent survey, 75.9% of women said they were unwilling to use it, as did 60.9% of men — a 68.8% average for all, according to a study by InsuranceQuotes. The numbers are not much better for Prime members, with only 34.3% saying they are willing to use Amazon Key. This contrasts with 63.7% who trust Amazon in general, versus 53% for Google and 27.9% for Facebook,” (Alaimo, March 16th 2018). This data shows that although they feel comfortable with the cameras throughout their lives constantly, they also know when the monitoring is excessive and infiltrates in their lives too much. They feel that this is crossing a boundary, not just the doorway, but privacy.
        Although there is this breach of privacy there are ways in which one can avoid that. One way is to entirely boycott the product. By not allowing this item into a home there is a 0% chance that it will cause a home invasion and thus an invasion of privacy. By not allowing the product into one’s home there is also no chance that a rogue delivery person can get into the home to deliver the package, steal anything, or plan on breaking and entering because he/she has no idea what is inside the house.
        What is another way in which one can avoid the invasion of privacy? The company itself could change its privacy policy so it is more user friendly and does not coerce the buyer with an onslaught of lengthy phrases that are incomprehensible to the normal citizen who has no background in English or business. By making the policy more understandable to the normal everyday person there would be less confusion in what they are signing up for, this would make it so people do not get angry when they see that something did not go the way they wanted/expected.
How could the breach privacy of the delivery people be solved? Amazon should make it optional to do these in-home deliveries. Those workers who feel comfortable doing them should be able to opt-in to these assignments while those who are not should be able to opt-out. Buy doing this those that are allergic to anything would be able to not have to enter homes where strange substances may be in the air which can cause them to have allergic reactions. This also makes it so those deliver men/women who are afraid of animals or are fond of them get the chance to either not deal with or deal with these animals/ pets of the homeowners. By allowing the workers to opt-in/out of these in-home deliveries, they would feel more comfortable and safe while on the job leading to less lawsuits against Amazon, saving them millions of dollars.
Within the interview conducted by Forbes with Jeff Bezos, the owner of Amazon, they asked him a flurry of questions which he answered each one. When asked about his company and how they are working with different hardwares, possibly the Amazon Key, he said "You have to be patient. It's not going to be just time to learn a skill. It might take time for the thing to really flower." (Lane, 2018). This goes to show that even though there is slight failure or lack of skill when it comes to some aspects of the products of Amazon he remains optimistic and wishes to make these policies that go along with the hardwares they sell. As the company grows so does the products they produce, some of these products may be softwares, some hardware like the Amazon Key, and these will be improved in the future as they gain the necessary skills.
Privacy, such a fragile topic than not many want to delve into. But with the Amazon Key and so many other products on the horizon it's about time someone was to get down to business and bring it up. Whether the privacy of the homeowner be broken or the delivery people that have to do these package drop offs within the home. Everyone involved with these types of products are being taken advantage of in some way when it comes to privacy. The cameras and keypads that are involved with the Key are connected to the internet so they can be hacked into very easily. The delivery people could be bent and end up selling some homes to burglars just to make an “extra buck”. But there are ways in which one can avoid these problems. One can avoid the product entirely, or they can push the company to move the policies into a more user-friendly direction. Another way is that they can have the workers request to opt-in/out of the in-home deliveries. All of these are great ways in which people can avoid being hurt by the lack of privacy that the Amazon Key puts them though. Privacy is important and should not be taken for granted. The Amazon Key is a breach of privacy and there needs to be improvements made to the system.

(1)   Privacy. (n.) In Oxford English Dictionary. Retrieved from http://www.oed.com.ez.lib.jjay.cuny.edu/view/Entry/151596?redirectedFrom=privacy&
(2)   TEKDOĞAN, R., & EFE, A. (2018). Prevention Techniques for SSL Hacking Threats to E-Government Services. International Journal of Information Security Science, 7(2), 67–77. Retrieved from http://ez.lib.jjay.cuny.edu/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=131283289&site=ehost-live
(3)CBS News, Nov. 17th 2018, Retrieved from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bh3TsxslJJc
(4) Chief Brandon del Pozo, 2018, Body Cameras and Privacy - Where do you Draw the Line? Retrieved from: https://www.policefoundation.org/body-cameras-and-privacy-where-do-you-draw-the-line/
(5) United States Department of Labor, 1960
Employee reports of unsafe or unhealthful working conditions.Retrieved from:
https://www.osha.gov/pls/oshaweb/owadisp.show_document?p_id=11279&p_table=STANDARDS
 (6)  Dan Alaimo, March 16th 2018. 70% of consumers unwilling to use Amazon Key
https://www.retaildive.com/news/70-of-consumers-unwilling-to-use-amazon-key/519296/

(7) Randall Lane, 2018. Bezos Unbound: Exclusive Interview With The Amazon Founder On What He Plans To Conquer Next. Retrieved from:
https://www.forbes.com/sites/randalllane/2018/08/30/bezos-unbound-exclusive-interview-with-the-amazon-founder-on-what-he-plans-to-conquer-next/#941b4c7647b8

No comments:

Post a Comment